Is being a patriot a good thing?


I am a proud South African. Unfortunately, this statement is selective. I am proud to be South African when my country shines on the sports field, and I am not proud when my country stands idly by as politicians mock an entire country, rape it’s economy and destroy it’s foreign relations. I am proudly South African when my country stands up out of the ashes of apartheid to show the world what peace and love really means, and I am ashamed when those who have stood now start fires of corruption, setting South Africa on a similar path to that of its Zimbabwean neighbour.

Some might argue that this is the epitome of a patriot. Someone who wants nothing but the best for and from their country. And if this were the true definition of patriotism, then I would gladly call myself a patriot. But it is not. In these modern times, patriotism has become a system of division. We drew lines on maps, copied them into the real world where we could now patrol these borders to protect the people on this side of the line from everyone on the other side of the line.

Picture a fenced yard, filled with children. We draw lines on the ground, an then tell some of the children that they can cross their lines and go anywhere they want, but other children must be stuck where they are. Each area is special in its own way. Has it’s own creatures, it’s own toys and it’s own rules. Some children want the toys in someone else’s area, and will cross the line to get it. If the other child protests, there will be a fight, a fight that the other children stand around watching because they are not allowed to leave their area. Eventually some person in charge will show up and ask what’s going on. The child who crossed the line might own up to what they did, but he probably likes the toy he came for, so he claims that it was his and he just came over to fetch it. The rest of the children know that the Authority figure will not be around forever, and so are reluctant to accuse the bully, fearing later reprisals. Having no-one willing to gainsay him, the bully now begins his slow domination of the entire yard. Another child decides that he doesn’t like the rules in his neighbour’s area, so he decides to go over there and to take his rules, and everyone else who follows the same rules, with him. Power struggles will eventually break out, with some of the children forming alliances and eventually, with safety existing in numbers, several factions form throughout the yard. Some of the children build walls on their lines, to keep their neighbours out. Others form powerful groups, who move freely within the group area, but protect their outer lines. Raids begin, lies are told, individuals are hurt, spying, mudslinging, tyranny, genocide, untill there are only a few children left, and the yard is unrecognizable. The rules have all been twisted and warped along with the children. All the fascinating creatures are gone. All the toys are broken. The remaining children have grown bitter, distrusting, vengeful and desperate. What could have been a wonderful yard, has become a living hell. All because of a few lines. Funny that.

I approve of cultural awareness. Knowing your roots can be vital to many people. And the rich cultural heritage that is the quilt of humanity is a wonder to behold. But nationalism has crossed the line between cultural conservation and cultural erosion.

Religious beliefs have supported entire millions of needful people for thousands of years, given aid to their own wherever they were needed. But the promised land-syndrome has now cost enough lives to populate another planet, and I cannot believe that that is what the religious system’s purpose is.

Competitive spirit is healthy, it encourages growth. But growth, when it is not spread and shared, creates divides even greater than the lines we have already drawn.

I do not mind the labeling of an area on a map. It is both useful, practical. But they should stay on paper, before we’re left with nothing but a broken down yard filled with desperate children. We need a world where borders are used only to streamline the tracking of our very precious natural resources. Immigration laws, empowering the few while the many remain caged in lands that will mean their death, serve no purpose other than the economic manipulation of labour prices. Governments and nations are, in the end, just people, and we need to remember that as people we have a responsibility to everything and everyone we need for the world to function properly.

- Written by Pieter De Beer


Part of the Johannesburg TZM chapter and contributor to the website.

Tagged with: , , ,
Posted in Opinion
One comment on “Is being a patriot a good thing?
  1. Ryan Wyche Taylor says:

    Thank you pieter De Beer for this well written and inspirational article. I for one also firmly believe in clearing this system of division and in spreading such ideas. #TZM

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


+ 2 = nine

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Facebook Feed

  • Wake Up Call

    Join the conversation: #WakeUpCall. Find out more at Have you ever felt like we're living through a nightmare of co...

  • Timeline Photos
    TZM works not only to create awareness of such problems and their true root causes (and hence logic for resolution), it also works to express the incredible potential we have, beyond such direct problem solving, to greatly improve the human condition in general, solving problems which, in fact, have not yet even been realized. This is initiated by embracing the very nature of scientific reasoning where the establishment of a near empirical train of thought takes precedence over everything else in importance. A train of thought by which societal organization as a whole can find a more accurate context for sustainability and efficiency on a scale never before seen, through an active recognition (and application) of the scientific method. TZM Defined Book:

  • Are the robots about to rise? Google's new director of engineering thinks so…
    Ray Kurzweil popularised the 'singularity' concept, when artificial intelligence overtakes human thinking. Now he is trying to make it a reality for Google. Carole Cadwalladr meets him

    Free Software Foundation statement on the new iPhone, Apple Pay, and Apple Watch — Free Software...
    Free Software Foundation statement on the new iPhone, Apple Pay, and Apple Watch by Free Software Foundation Contributions — Published on Sep 09, 2014 02:14 PM The Free Software Foundation encourages users to avoid all Apple products, in the interest of their own freedom and the freedom of those aro…

    Photos from Jenny Slack's post in Sacred Economics with Charles Eisenstein
    For those of you who may be in Cape Town (or know someone there who would be interested in attending), here are details of the Cape Town event organised by SAFCEI and taking place on Thursday, 4 September at UCT. To RSVP or for more info, contact Zainab: ........................................................................... Our present economic system is not overcoming poverty, unemployment, inequality and environmental destruction. On the contrary, it is the driving force behind them. It is urgent that we seek a more just economic system that confronts poverty and inequitable distribution of the planet’s abundant resources, and stems the destruction of nature, our life support system. There is now an emerging movement of thinkers searching for alternatives to our current neo-liberal economic system which is based on perpetual growth. Charles Eisenstein, in his book Sacred Economics, does not call for a revolution, but a transformation of our economics. Central to this is the understanding that we are an integral part of the web of life. Human well-being is dependent on the well-being of the planet. SAFCEI highlights the following: ● Ours is a planet of abundance: we have made it one of scarcity. ● The spirit of Ubuntu should be at the centre of our concerns and goals. ● Growth should be for human development and welfare, not economic wealth. ● Ethical principles, not profits, should guide our decision-making. ● If we value sustainability and well-being over wealth accumulation, people won’t resort to drastic means to survive. ● Recognising spiritual and cultural values enables us to appreciate natural wonders. ● Mechanization and high tech, high energy capital development does people out of jobs. Low carbon, labour intensive employment, industry and investment will overcome poverty, unemployment and inequality. This in turn will help restore the health of the planet, and confront climate change. ● Faith, principles of justice, equity, fairness and compassion can transform the quality of our lives and communities.